An Apology for the Edition of Francis Kaplan
Brémondy, François
An Apology for the Edition of Francis Kaplan - 2009.
35
Pascal prepared an Apology for the Christian religion. At his death, his friends found only a thousand isolated notes. The majority of current specialists, however, have adopted the position of Louis Lafuma, restated by Jean Mesnard, according to which 1) the copy of the notes made after Pascal’s death reproduces the order that he himself had in mind for following his work, and 2) it was Pascal himself who gathered these notes in bundles, each of which corresponds to a chapter of the work. Francis Kaplan refutes these two hypotheses on two grounds : first, the order followed by the copy is too illogical to be attributed to Pascal ; and secondly, certain bundles contain papers treating subjects too highly varied to correspond to chapters. Kaplan, on the other hand, proposes a classification deduced from about fifty indications regarding the plan which appears in the manuscripts, and which are, as such, beyond dispute.
An Apology for the Edition of Francis Kaplan - 2009.
35
Pascal prepared an Apology for the Christian religion. At his death, his friends found only a thousand isolated notes. The majority of current specialists, however, have adopted the position of Louis Lafuma, restated by Jean Mesnard, according to which 1) the copy of the notes made after Pascal’s death reproduces the order that he himself had in mind for following his work, and 2) it was Pascal himself who gathered these notes in bundles, each of which corresponds to a chapter of the work. Francis Kaplan refutes these two hypotheses on two grounds : first, the order followed by the copy is too illogical to be attributed to Pascal ; and secondly, certain bundles contain papers treating subjects too highly varied to correspond to chapters. Kaplan, on the other hand, proposes a classification deduced from about fifty indications regarding the plan which appears in the manuscripts, and which are, as such, beyond dispute.
Réseaux sociaux