Influence de la profondeur temporelle d’anticipation sur la charge cognitive en environnement aéronautique
Lini, Sami
Influence de la profondeur temporelle d’anticipation sur la charge cognitive en environnement aéronautique - 2015.
66
L’anticipation est l’une des clés de voûte de la capacité humaine à gérer les situations critiques. L’aéronautique civile constitue un environnement dynamique où les enjeux de sécurité sont très forts. Aider les pilotes à mieux anticiper constitue donc un défi majeur que le projet ASAP (Anticipation Support for Aeronautical Planning) vise à relever. Une question soulevée très tôt par la psychologie cognitive concerne la relation entre la profondeur temporelle d’anticipation et la charge cognitive. Pour proposer un outil fournissant des informations permettant de mieux anticiper, cette question doit être traitée. Dans le cadre d’un simulateur aéronautique, une expérimentation a été réalisée pour investiguer l’influence de la profondeur temporelle de présentation d’informations servant l’activité sur la charge cognitive d’opérateurs. Le protocole de mesures croisées mis en œuvre, la démarche d’analyse de l’activité préalable à l’expérimentation ainsi que les résultats significatifs sont présentés. L’apparition d’un compromis cognitif entre information nécessaire et coût induit par son traitement est mise en avant et commentée. Anticipation is one of the cornerstones of the human capacity to manage critical situations. Various studies have addressed anticipatory and predictive cognitive processes distinctly in situations with slow and rapid dynamics. Their results indicate a need for effective anticipation, which contributes to reducing cognitive load while preserving optimal performance. Commercial aviation is dynamic environment in which safety stakes are high. Helping pilots to better anticipate constitutes a major challenge that the ASAP (Anticipation Support for Aeronautical Planning) project addresses. Flying a plane during landing phase has the particularity of implying both short-term anticipation (managing flight variables) and long-term anticipation (managing the flight path and getting ready to the landing). One early question raised by the cognitive psychology field is about the relationship between anticipatory time depth and cognitive load. In order to offer a tool providing information to help pilots better anticipate, this issue must be dealt with. In a simulated civil aviation setting, we implemented an experiment in order to investigate the relationship between anticipatory time depth – the time between the moment when information is presented and the moment when it is used – and how cognitive load evolves at a predetermined level of control. We chose to investigate a civil aviation setting where the tasks to be performed have fixed terms defined by flight procedures and the dynamics of the aircraft. This means that subjects can prepare to take action (anticipation by preparation for action), but they cannot pro-act (anticipation by pro-action). Cognitive load is also assessed. It is also expected to observe an “optimal time depth”, i.e. a “time depth beyond which the information-processing-induced overload is not compensated by what this information adds to the representation of the situation”. To address the hypotheses stated above we chose “radar” type guidance, i.e. guidance for instrument flight where the subject enters instructions relating to altitude, speed and heading into the autopilot which does not require any particular technical skills to be mastered. The results are presented as well as the ergonomics and knowledge management approaches implemented in order to design the experimental setup. The appearance of a cognitive compromise is highlighted and discussed. Conclusions are drawn from the results in order to design an effective anticipation support for pilots.
Influence de la profondeur temporelle d’anticipation sur la charge cognitive en environnement aéronautique - 2015.
66
L’anticipation est l’une des clés de voûte de la capacité humaine à gérer les situations critiques. L’aéronautique civile constitue un environnement dynamique où les enjeux de sécurité sont très forts. Aider les pilotes à mieux anticiper constitue donc un défi majeur que le projet ASAP (Anticipation Support for Aeronautical Planning) vise à relever. Une question soulevée très tôt par la psychologie cognitive concerne la relation entre la profondeur temporelle d’anticipation et la charge cognitive. Pour proposer un outil fournissant des informations permettant de mieux anticiper, cette question doit être traitée. Dans le cadre d’un simulateur aéronautique, une expérimentation a été réalisée pour investiguer l’influence de la profondeur temporelle de présentation d’informations servant l’activité sur la charge cognitive d’opérateurs. Le protocole de mesures croisées mis en œuvre, la démarche d’analyse de l’activité préalable à l’expérimentation ainsi que les résultats significatifs sont présentés. L’apparition d’un compromis cognitif entre information nécessaire et coût induit par son traitement est mise en avant et commentée. Anticipation is one of the cornerstones of the human capacity to manage critical situations. Various studies have addressed anticipatory and predictive cognitive processes distinctly in situations with slow and rapid dynamics. Their results indicate a need for effective anticipation, which contributes to reducing cognitive load while preserving optimal performance. Commercial aviation is dynamic environment in which safety stakes are high. Helping pilots to better anticipate constitutes a major challenge that the ASAP (Anticipation Support for Aeronautical Planning) project addresses. Flying a plane during landing phase has the particularity of implying both short-term anticipation (managing flight variables) and long-term anticipation (managing the flight path and getting ready to the landing). One early question raised by the cognitive psychology field is about the relationship between anticipatory time depth and cognitive load. In order to offer a tool providing information to help pilots better anticipate, this issue must be dealt with. In a simulated civil aviation setting, we implemented an experiment in order to investigate the relationship between anticipatory time depth – the time between the moment when information is presented and the moment when it is used – and how cognitive load evolves at a predetermined level of control. We chose to investigate a civil aviation setting where the tasks to be performed have fixed terms defined by flight procedures and the dynamics of the aircraft. This means that subjects can prepare to take action (anticipation by preparation for action), but they cannot pro-act (anticipation by pro-action). Cognitive load is also assessed. It is also expected to observe an “optimal time depth”, i.e. a “time depth beyond which the information-processing-induced overload is not compensated by what this information adds to the representation of the situation”. To address the hypotheses stated above we chose “radar” type guidance, i.e. guidance for instrument flight where the subject enters instructions relating to altitude, speed and heading into the autopilot which does not require any particular technical skills to be mastered. The results are presented as well as the ergonomics and knowledge management approaches implemented in order to design the experimental setup. The appearance of a cognitive compromise is highlighted and discussed. Conclusions are drawn from the results in order to design an effective anticipation support for pilots.
Réseaux sociaux