Les dérives sectaires en santé : comparaison entre la France et la Suisse (notice n° 656152)
[ vue normale ]
| 000 -LEADER | |
|---|---|
| fixed length control field | 04097cam a2200349 4500500 |
| 005 - DATE AND TIME OF LATEST TRANSACTION | |
| control field | 20250121190759.0 |
| 041 ## - LANGUAGE CODE | |
| Language code of text/sound track or separate title | fre |
| 042 ## - AUTHENTICATION CODE | |
| Authentication code | dc |
| 100 10 - MAIN ENTRY--PERSONAL NAME | |
| Personal name | Berna, Fabrice |
| Relator term | author |
| 245 00 - TITLE STATEMENT | |
| Title | Les dérives sectaires en santé : comparaison entre la France et la Suisse |
| 260 ## - PUBLICATION, DISTRIBUTION, ETC. | |
| Date of publication, distribution, etc. | 2024.<br/> |
| 500 ## - GENERAL NOTE | |
| General note | 12 |
| 520 ## - SUMMARY, ETC. | |
| Summary, etc. | Dans la partie 1 de notre étude, nous avions clarifié les définitions de « dérives sectaires » ainsi que les réponses politiques et juridiques à ces dérives en France et en Suisse. Cette seconde partie se concentre sur la méthodologie d’évaluation des dérives sectaires dans le domaine de la santé et sur l’analyse des données disponibles pour observer leur évolution au fil du temps. Les statistiques les plus accessibles étant celles des saisines ou des signalements en santé adressées à la MIVILUDES en France ou au CIC en Suisse, nous observons qu’ils ne sont pas directement indicatifs de « dérives sectaire en santé ». Nous proposons ensuite une analyse critique et comparative des méthodes employées par ces deux institutions ainsi qu’une évaluation des chiffres. Nos analyses montrent une relative stabilité des demandes adressées au CIC au sujet de la santé holistique entre 2002 et 2023, alors que le recours à ces pratiques a graduellement progressé en Suisse et a été réglementé par la loi de 2009. En France, le nombre de saisines adressées à la MIVILUDES relatives à la santé a augmenté jusqu’en 2017 puis s’est stabilisé ensuite. Les chiffres de la MIVILUDES concernant les signalements dans le domaine de la santé manquent cependant de précision, en particulier ceux relatifs aux pratiques de soins non conventionnelles. Nous discutons ces chiffres en soulignant l’asymétrie entre expertise scientifique et communication politico-médiatique d’une part et l’écart entre les chiffres disponibles et certaines affirmations d’une augmentation des dérives sectaires en santé depuis la pandémie. |
| 520 ## - SUMMARY, ETC. | |
| Summary, etc. | In the first part of our paper, we clarified the definitions of “sectarian drifts” and the political and legal responses to these drifts in France and Switzerland. This second part focuses on the methodology for assessing sectarian drifts in the healthcare field, and on the analysis of available data to observe their evolution over time. As the most accessible statistics are those on health-related referrals or reports sent to MIVILUDES in France or the CIC in Switzerland, we clarify that they are not directly indicative of “sectarian drifts related to health”. We then propose a critical and comparative analysis of the methods used by these two institutions, and an assessment of the figures. Our analyses show a relative stability in referrals to the CIC on the subject of holistic health between 2002 and 2023, while the use of these practices has gradually increased in Switzerland, regulated by the 2009 law. In France, the number of health-related referrals to MIVILUDES increased until 2017, then stabilized. MIVILUDES’ figures for health-related referrals are not precise, particularly those related to unconventional healthcare practices. We discuss these figures, highlighting the asymmetry between academic expertise and political and media communication on the one hand, and the discrepancy between the available figures and certain assertions of an increase in sectarian drifts in healthcare since the pandemic on the other. |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | signalement |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | saisine |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | Santé holistique |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | dérive thérapeutique |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | rapports |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | dérive sectaire |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | méthodologie |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | methodology |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | sectarian drifts |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | reports |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | referral |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | Holistic health |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | reporting |
| 690 ## - LOCAL SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM (OCLC, RLIN) | |
| Topical term or geographic name as entry element | therapeutic drifts |
| 700 10 - ADDED ENTRY--PERSONAL NAME | |
| Personal name | Farahmand, Manéli |
| Relator term | author |
| 786 0# - DATA SOURCE ENTRY | |
| Note | Hegel | 14 | 2 | 2024-07-11 | p. 175-194 | 2269-0530 |
| 856 41 - ELECTRONIC LOCATION AND ACCESS | |
| Uniform Resource Identifier | <a href="https://shs.cairn.info/revue-hegel-2024-2-page-175?lang=fr&redirect-ssocas=7080">https://shs.cairn.info/revue-hegel-2024-2-page-175?lang=fr&redirect-ssocas=7080</a> |
Pas d'exemplaire disponible.
Réseaux sociaux